[Share Experiences] better-wubi 数据帖(对比原版 86、98、新世纪)
Tofloor
poster avatar
beavailable
deepin
2022-02-18 02:28
Author

这是一个数据帖,记录了一些统计数据,供大家参考。

相关主题:86五笔输入法改进版 better-wubi(码表)

来源

原版 8698新世纪的码表均来源于此仓库:https://github.com/CNMan/rime-data,只取单字(和 better-wubi中的单字做交集),然后和 better-wubi中的词库组合而成。

各码表来源文件名如下:

  • 86: wubi86_jishuang.dict.yaml
  • 98: wubi98_yuqiong.dict.yaml
  • 新世纪: wubi06_tygfhzb.dict.yaml

数据

本数据统计的是各码表中的 按键使用率 重码率

86

单字比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-5.2% | W-4.9% | E-3.3% | R-2.9% | T-5.6% | Y-5.6% | U-4.0% | I-4.0% | O-1.8% | P-2.8% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.5% | S-2.9% | D-4.9% | F-6.1% | G-6.9% | H-4.4% | J-4.3% | K-4.9% | L-2.4% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.2% | C-2.7% | V-2.5% | B-2.3% | N-5.2% | M-3.6% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 26015,左右比例为 57.0%:43.0%

词组比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.6% | W-5.9% | E-2.6% | R-4.4% | T-7.0% | Y-5.8% | U-4.7% | I-4.8% | O-1.5% | P-3.5% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.5% | S-3.5% | D-5.0% | F-6.3% | G-6.9% | H-3.5% | J-3.1% | K-3.8% | L-2.3% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.2% | C-2.2% | V-2.3% | B-2.4% | N-4.1% | M-3.1% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 684052,左右比例为 59.6%:40.4%

单字重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |    7446    |    373     |    5.0%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |    7836    |    390     |    5.0%    |
-----------------------------------------------

词组重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |   104043   |   36207    |   34.8%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |   171013   |   66970    |   39.2%    |
-----------------------------------------------

98

单字比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.9% | W-5.3% | E-3.5% | R-3.2% | T-5.7% | Y-5.4% | U-4.3% | I-3.6% | O-2.3% | P-2.7% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.4% | S-3.4% | D-4.5% | F-5.9% | G-7.7% | H-4.5% | J-4.1% | K-4.9% | L-2.0% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.3% | C-2.7% | V-2.4% | B-2.4% | N-4.9% | M-3.0% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 25912,左右比例为 58.2%:41.8%

词组比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.1% | W-6.3% | E-2.8% | R-4.2% | T-7.3% | Y-5.2% | U-4.8% | I-4.6% | O-2.2% | P-3.5% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.3% | S-3.8% | D-5.3% | F-5.9% | G-7.0% | H-3.7% | J-3.0% | K-3.8% | L-1.9% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.2% | C-2.3% | V-2.2% | B-2.6% | N-4.1% | M-2.5% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 684220,左右比例为 60.5%:39.5%

单字重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |    7598    |    378     |    5.0%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |    7993    |    395     |    4.9%    |
-----------------------------------------------

词组重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |   104149   |   35823    |   34.4%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |   171055   |   66906    |   39.1%    |
-----------------------------------------------

新世纪

单字比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.7% | W-5.2% | E-3.6% | R-3.1% | T-5.4% | Y-6.0% | U-3.8% | I-3.7% | O-2.3% | P-2.6% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.3% | S-2.9% | D-4.5% | F-6.1% | G-8.1% | H-4.8% | J-4.0% | K-5.2% | L-2.0% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.2% | C-2.8% | V-2.2% | B-2.2% | N-5.1% | M-3.0% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 28198,左右比例为 57.5%:42.5%

词组比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.1% | W-6.3% | E-2.8% | R-4.6% | T-7.0% | Y-5.4% | U-4.4% | I-4.6% | O-2.2% | P-3.4% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.5% | S-3.5% | D-5.3% | F-6.1% | G-7.0% | H-3.9% | J-3.0% | K-4.1% | L-2.0% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.2% | C-2.2% | V-2.1% | B-2.4% | N-4.1% | M-2.6% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 684300,左右比例为 60.3%:39.7%

单字重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |    7649    |    426     |    5.6%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |    8105    |    456     |    5.6%    |
-----------------------------------------------

词组重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |   103734   |   35982    |   34.7%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |   171075   |   67341    |   39.4%    |
-----------------------------------------------

better-wubi

单字比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.7% | W-4.9% | E-3.6% | R-3.0% | T-4.7% | Y-5.4% | U-4.0% | I-3.9% | O-2.5% | P-3.3% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.5% | S-3.0% | D-4.9% | F-5.8% | G-6.5% | H-4.4% | J-4.4% | K-5.0% | L-2.8% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.3% | C-2.8% | V-2.5% | B-2.2% | N-5.2% | M-3.6% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 27197,左右比例为 55.5%:44.5%

词组比例:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Q-4.3% | W-5.8% | E-2.9% | R-4.7% | T-6.2% | Y-5.4% | U-4.8% | I-4.7% | O-2.0% | P-3.6% |
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 | A-4.5% | S-3.6% | D-5.5% | F-5.9% | G-6.0% | H-3.6% | J-3.3% | K-3.9% | L-2.7% |
 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   | Z      | X-2.3% | C-2.2% | V-2.3% | B-2.4% | N-4.1% | M-3.1% |
   ----------------------------------------------------------------
总计 684320,左右比例为 58.7%:41.3%

单字重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |    7677    |    413     |    5.4%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |    8112    |    435     |    5.4%    |
-----------------------------------------------

词组重码:
-----------------------------------------------
| 指标 |    总计    |    重码    |    比例    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 编码 |   107460   |   36345    |   33.8%    |
-----------------------------------------------
| 字词 |   171080   |   63620    |   37.2%    |
-----------------------------------------------

结论

在按键均衡度方面,better-wubi表现是最好的。

在单字重码率方面,虽然 8698单字不全,但应该比 新世纪better-wubi表现更好,新世纪表现是最差的。

在词组重码率方面,better-wubi表现是最好的。

Reply Favorite View the author
All Replies
sammy-621
deepin
2022-02-18 03:01
#1

Deepin自带的是哪个版本?

Reply View the author
beavailable
deepin
2022-02-18 03:05
#2
sammy-621

Deepin自带的是哪个版本?

应该是 86

Reply View the author
thepoy
deepin
2022-02-18 03:59
#3

98用户表示看不出你这个 better 在哪里

Reply View the author
Comments
beavailable
2022-02-18 15:52
看不出来就算了,不要勉强自己。
andktan
deepin
2022-02-18 05:53
#4

有心了

Reply View the author